Retention marketing agency for DTC brands

We make your customers stick.

Email, SMS, loyalty and subscription programs that turn first orders into repeat customers. Built and run in whichever platform you already use.

3 to 5 days. Manager access and an NDA. Yours to keep. We start up to 15 new brands per quarter.

Retention only since 2019 Platform agnostic
25% to 40%

Share of store revenue our clients usually see come from email within six months

35 to 40

Pages in your free retention audit, delivered in 3 to 5 days

8 weeks

The most a Klaviyo migration takes with us, start to finish

2019

The year we started. Retention only, ever since. About us

The work

Emails we've built for brands you know

Browse case studies
Trusted by DTC brands including
  • KEEN
  • Tatcha
  • Melissa and Doug
  • MUD WTR
  • KISS
  • ZO Skin Health
  • American Optical
  • Hanky Panky
  • PrettyLitter
  • Rylee and Cru
  • Gardencup
  • GLDN
  • Tubby Todd
  • Berne
  • IM8
  • Nest New York
Results

Numbers we can show you

Real figures from real client programs. Every case study shows the data behind it.

See all case studies
Vertical
Program

Kudos
+356%

Klaviyo-attributed revenue, January to October 2026 vs. 2025, from $834K to $3.8M.

Baby and kidsSubscription
Read the case study
Alaskan Salmon Co.
+260%

Attributed revenue, January 2025 to January 2026 vs. the prior 13 months, from $221K to $798K.

Food and beverageSubscription
Read the case study
Maggy London
+386%

Klaviyo-attributed revenue, 2023 to 2024, from $221K to $1.08M.

Apparel and accessories
Read the case study
Gardencup
+163%

Owned-audience revenue over BFCM 2025 vs. 2024, from $72K to $191K.

Food and beverage
Read the case study
Refresh Gum
+420%

Flow revenue from September to December 2025, around a product launch.

Food and beverage
Read the case study
Tubby Todd
+30%

Flow revenue in Q2 2024 vs. Q2 2023, from $831K to $1.08M.

Baby and kidsSubscription
Read the case study
Melanie Auld
+40%

Owned revenue in Q1 2025 vs. Q1 2024, from $437K to $612K.

Apparel and accessories
Read the case study
Maison Miru
+43%

Flow revenue, January to May 2026 vs. 2025, from $507K to $725K.

Apparel and accessories
Read the case study
U Beauty
+$1.5M

More Klaviyo revenue year over year, for a brand where email once drove under 10% of attributed revenue.

Beauty and personal care
Read the case study
U Beauty
500+

Loyalty wallet passes added at launch, which opened push notifications as a new owned channel.

Beauty and personal care
Read the case study
r.e.m. beauty
+30.6%

Pop-up submit rate, from 2.1% to 2.8%, from one test on when the pop-up appears.

Beauty and personal care
Read the case study
Sigma Beauty
+49%

Monthly attributed revenue from February to April 2025, from $93K to $138K.

Beauty and personal care
Read the case study
Deborah Lippmann
+78%

SMS revenue year over year, alongside a new loyalty program.

Beauty and personal care
Read the case study
Divi
+123%

Email campaign revenue month over month, from affinity-based segmentation.

Beauty and personal careSubscription
Read the case study
Carve Designs
$1M+

Klaviyo-attributed revenue in the first three months after a migration.

Apparel and accessories
Read the case study
Legend Headwear
45x

Return on investment from launching an SMS program.

Apparel and accessories
Read the case study
Danrie
+225%

Klaviyo-attributed email revenue, built on progressive profiling.

Baby and kids
Read the case study
Elix
-20%

Churn from flows, from subscription-focused lifecycle marketing.

Health and wellnessSubscription
Read the case study
Routine Wellness
99.9%

Delivered on the first send from a new sending domain, switched over the same day the new site launched.

Health and wellness
Read the case study
Proov
+52%

Total sales in the two weeks after a new site launched.

Health and wellness
Read the case study
Uqora
4

Buyer personas built from real customer service data.

Health and wellness
Read the case study
Melissa & Doug
+38.2%

Klaviyo revenue, year over year, against the same period one year earlier.

Baby and kids
Read the case study
Hanky Panky
+80%

Click-through rate, April to May 2026 vs. April to May 2025.

Apparel and accessories
Read the case study
XMONDO
+72.3%

SMS revenue per recipient during the engagement, late 2024 to March 2026.

Beauty and personal care
Read the case study
Sleepy Tie
+27.4%

Attributed revenue in the first 90 days, June 9 to September 6, 2026, vs. the 90 days before.

Beauty and personal care
Read the case study
Clevr Blends
+57%

SMS revenue over BFCM vs. the year before, from about $76K.

Food and beverage
Read the case study
Calaswim
+1,100%

Total attributed revenue in the first 30 days, starting August 2025.

Apparel and accessories
Read the case study
Smith Teamaker
+75%

Flow placed-order rate after a time delay and filter audit. Dates not disclosed.

Food and beverageSubscription
Read the case study
What we do

Everything retention. Nothing else.

We don't run paid media. We make the customers you've already won buy again, buy more and stay, in whichever platform you already use.

All services

Email marketing

Flows, campaigns and segmentation built around how your customers actually buy. Strategy, copy, design and build, all in house.

Explore services

SMS marketing

List growth, flows and campaigns that earn their place on someone's phone, planned alongside email instead of against it.

Explore services

Loyalty and subscription

Programs that turn a second order into a habit. When you need a closer look, our deep dive audits are $1,500 each.

Explore services

Platform migrations

Moves to Klaviyo, Attentive or Postscript without losing flows, data or deliverability. Klaviyo migrations take eight weeks at most.

See migrations

Deliverability

Authentication, sender reputation and inbox placement, checked and fixed before they quietly cost you revenue.

Explore services

Tech stack and CRO

Lean Shopify tech stacks and sign-up capture built to convert, with a roadmap that holds up as you grow.

Explore services
Sound familiar?

Six leaks we find most often. Which one is yours?

Each comes straight from our audits, and each has a full write-up on our blog. Pick the one that sounds like your account.

Recognize one? The free audit shows where it's happening in your account →

How we start

A real audit first. Then a plan.

No pitch deck. We look inside your account and show you exactly where revenue is leaking.

01

Free audit

35 to 40 pages on your flows, campaigns, segments and deliverability. Delivered in 3 to 5 days, with Manager access and an NDA.

02

Prioritized roadmap

Every audit closes with a roadmap ranked by what moves revenue first. Yours to keep, whether or not we work together.

03

Build

We rebuild the flows, campaigns and capture points that matter most, in the platform you already use.

04

Test and report

We test, measure and report on revenue, then keep improving what's working.

Get my free 35+ page audit

3 to 5 days. Manager access and an NDA. Yours to keep.

Clients

Why our clients stay

Extremely helpful and involved as an agency. They are willing to get into the work, doing anything they can to help propel our business. They deliver brilliant strategy and execution; always mindful of what else they can be doing to impact sales. Well-rounded team of digital experts. Fantastic team to work with.
Niki W.Marketing Manager at RUDIS
The Sticky team has great communication and great marketing ideas. They've been a key player in our business growth, doubling our annual revenue with their strategies! I also just genuinely look forward to talking to them regularly.
Shanna M.Digital Marketing Manager at Ascent Nutrition
The team at Sticky has made it so easy to ramp up and get started! They are always listening to our goals and what we are trying to achieve with our campaigns and have been phenomenal at bringing those to life! And, we are seeing our best results with SMS marketing than ever before!
Kerry G.Chief of Staff at Danrie
Partnerships

Platform agnostic. Well connected.

We don't sell you a platform. We work in whichever one fits your brand, and our relationships across the space help you get more out of it.

Also named Yotpo's #1 Retention Marketing Agency in North America, 2023 and 2024.

  • KlaviyoPlatinum Partner
  • AttentiveAdvisory Board
  • TieAdvisory Board
  • YotpoAdvisory Board
  • DigiohTop Partner
  • Hiro AnalyticsAdvisory Board
Free retention audit

What's included in the audit

Free, 35 to 40 pages, delivered in 3 to 5 days.

  • Flows

    Your welcome, abandoned cart, post-purchase and winback flows, each graded on logic, timing and revenue.

  • Campaigns

    Your recent email and SMS sends, graded on cadence, creative and results.

  • Segments

    How your list is split and targeted, graded against how your customers actually buy.

  • Deliverability

    Sender reputation, authentication and inbox placement, graded.

Where it applies, we also review your loyalty and subscription programs, and every audit closes with a prioritized roadmap. Deeper loyalty and subscription audits are $1,500 each. See our pricing.

Get my free 35+ page audit

3 to 5 days. Manager access and an NDA. Yours to keep.

Pricing
Retainers from $4,500 a month
  • Retention auditFree
  • Loyalty deep dive$1,500
  • Subscription deep dive$1,500
  • Klaviyo migration8 weeks max
See full pricing
FAQ

Questions we hear a lot

Straight answers on what we do, who we work with and what it costs.

Ask us something else

What is a retention marketing agency, and what does Sticky Digital do?

A retention marketing agency focuses on the customers a brand has already won: getting them to buy again, buy more and stay. Sticky Digital is a retention-only agency, founded in 2019. We run email, SMS, loyalty and subscription programs for DTC brands doing $5M or more, in whichever platform you already use. We are platform agnostic, with strong relationships across the space that help our clients succeed: Klaviyo Platinum Partner, Attentive Advisory Board, Tie Advisory Board, Yotpo Advisory Board, Hiro Analytics Advisory Board and Digioh Top Partner.

Who does Sticky Digital work with?

DTC brands on Shopify in beauty, wellness and supplements, kids and baby, consumables, and anything sold on subscription, including Murad, Tubby Todd and Alaskan Salmon Co..

What results should a brand expect?

Our clients usually see 25% to 40% of store revenue come from email within six months.

Does Sticky Digital handle migrations?

Yes. We migrate DTC brands to Klaviyo, Attentive or Postscript. A Klaviyo migration takes eight weeks at most, with a discount Sticky can secure. See migrations.

How does working with Sticky Digital start?

With a free retention audit: 35 to 40 pages, delivered in 3 to 5 days, based on Manager access to your account and an NDA. Deeper loyalty and subscription audits are $1,500 each.

What does Sticky Digital cost?

Retainers from $4,500 a month. See our pricing.

Let's stick together

You make the connections. We make them stick.

Get a 35 to 40 page audit of your retention program, free, and a roadmap that's yours to keep.

Get my free 35+ page audit

3 to 5 days. Manager access and an NDA. We start up to 15 new brands per quarter.

What happens after you book
  1. 01

    Your free audit

    Share Manager access and we sign an NDA. Your 35 to 40 page audit and roadmap arrive in 3 to 5 days, and they're yours to keep either way.

    3 to 5 days
  2. 02

    Onboarding

    If you want us to run it, you meet your producer, coordinator and designer, and we turn the audit into a prioritized plan for your first months.

    Once you say yes
  3. 03

    Your retainer

    We plan, build and test your program every month, from $4,500 a month. Six-month minimum, then month to month with 30 days notice.

    Month to month after six

Last updated