Melissa & Doug Case Study: 38% Klaviyo Revenue Growth Year Over Year, featured image from Sticky Digital

Melissa & Doug Case Study: 38% Klaviyo Revenue Growth Year Over Year

Last updated

Melissa & Doug grew Klaviyo revenue 38.2% year over year and more than doubled email click rate with Sticky Digital, while SMS revenue in Q1 2026 rose 123.7% year over year.

Baby and kids · Email, SMS and loyalty · Klaviyo and Attentive

+38.2%Klaviyo revenue, year over year
+117.8%Email click rate
+123.7%Q1 2026 SMS revenue, year over year

How we measured this

Results period: Q1 2026 for SMS, compared with Q1 2025. The other results are year over year. Email runs on Klaviyo and SMS on Attentive. This page was published on November 17, 2026.

Result Period Starting baseline How it is defined
Klaviyo revenue Year over year Same period one year earlier; value not disclosed Revenue from orders Klaviyo credits to an email or SMS message, using the account's attribution settings.
Email click rate Year over year Same period one year earlier; value not disclosed Share of delivered messages that received a click.
SMS revenue Q1 2026 Q1 2025, the same quarter one year earlier; value not disclosed Revenue the SMS platform named on this page attributes to text messages within its attribution window.
Klaviyo share of store revenue 12 months to November 17, 2026 Single-period share, no baseline Klaviyo-attributed revenue divided by total store revenue, from Hiro Analytics.

About Melissa & Doug

Melissa & Doug makes toys built around open-ended, screen-free play: wooden toys, puzzles, sticker pads and pretend play. Email runs on Klaviyo, SMS on Attentive, and the brand rewards repeat shoppers through its Play Perks loyalty program.

The challenge

Melissa & Doug needed a retention partner who could go beyond the basics. The brand sends to a large list on a busy promotional calendar, so it needed campaign execution, complex flow builds and loyalty strategy from one team, plus the testing discipline to know which creative actually earns revenue.

What we did

Sticky Digital runs the program day to day and treats every send as a chance to learn. The work includes:

  • A daily campaign calendar across email and SMS, built around franchises like Sale Toys, seasonal shipping cutoffs, themed newsletters and new arrivals.
  • Weekly email and SMS A/B test reporting. In Q1 2026 alone, seven campaign tests and two flow tests reached statistical significance.
  • A quarterly creative review that ranks every email, SMS and subject line by revenue and turns the findings into the next quarter’s briefs.
  • A new back-in-stock flow, QA’d and launched in October 2026.
  • Deliverability work ahead of holiday volume: spotting a bot-driven bounce spike in the first abandoned checkout email, fixing it, and running regular inbox placement tests.
  • Loyalty strategy for Play Perks, including the welcome flow for new members.

Do you know which of your emails actually earn the revenue?

Get my free audit

The results

Klaviyo revenue rose 38.2% year over year, email click rate rose 117.8%, and SMS campaign deliveries rose 96.5%. The Q1 2026 creative review showed where the growth came from and what to change next.

  • SMS was the highest yield channel. Sale Toys texts drove the top three single sends of Q1 2026, earning between $3,100 and $6,200 each, and SMS revenue rose 123.7% year over year.
  • Removing the auto-applied discount code from CTA links lifted revenue 28.1% in a statistically significant test, so the team changed how offers are linked across campaigns.
  • Easter emails sent at the standard and expedited shipping cutoffs outperformed the mid-promotion sends.
  • The best performing subject lines reached 75% to 82% open rates by leading with new arrivals and screen-free play.

Last 12 months, per Hiro Analytics: Klaviyo-attributed revenue made up 29.7% of Melissa & Doug’s store revenue in the 12 months to November 17, 2026.

“I don’t know what I would have done without Sticky Digital.”

Katie M., CRM and Lifecycle Marketing Manager, Melissa & Doug

Why it worked

The program runs on evidence. Every quarter the team ranks what earned and what did not, every week it reports on live tests, and the next round of creative is built from those results instead of from habit.

Want results like these?

Every Sticky Digital engagement starts with a free retention audit: 35 to 40 pages, delivered in 3 to 5 days. See our pricing and our retention services.

Get my free 35+ page audit

More results: all Sticky Digital case studies.

Back to blog