Hanky Panky Case Study: 80% Higher Click-Through Rate After a Retention Rebuild, featured image from Sticky Digital

Hanky Panky Case Study: 80% Higher Click-Through Rate After a Retention Rebuild

Last updated

Hanky Panky lifted click-through rate 80% and net email subscribes 40% year over year after rebuilding its direct-to-consumer retention program with Sticky Digital.

Intimates and apparel · March to September 2026 · Email, SMS, flows and list growth

+13%Campaign revenue per recipient, year over year
+40%Net email subscribes, year over year
+80%Click-through rate, year over year

How we measured this

Results period: April to May 2026, compared with April to May 2025. Sticky Digital took over the program in early 2026, and the engagement window runs from March to September 2026. This page was published on November 17, 2026.

Result Period Starting baseline How it is defined
Campaign revenue per recipient April to May 2026 Same period one year earlier; value not disclosed Campaign revenue divided by campaign recipients.
Net email subscribes April to May 2026 Same period one year earlier; value not disclosed New email subscribers minus unsubscribes.
Click-through rate April to May 2026 Same period one year earlier; value not disclosed Share of delivered messages that received a click.
Klaviyo share of store revenue 12 months to November 17, 2026 Single-period share, no baseline Klaviyo-attributed revenue divided by total store revenue, from Hiro Analytics.

About Hanky Panky

Hanky Panky makes intimates known for signature lace, plus everyday cotton styles, multipacks and seasonal colors, and has been in business for nearly five decades. Sticky Digital took over the brand’s email and SMS program in early 2026.

The challenge

Hanky Panky wanted to completely revamp its direct-to-consumer presence, take more ownership of its retention program and build a full-funnel retention experience for its customers. Several core automations were running through a separate winback vendor, so the brand did not fully control its own customer journey.

What we did

Sticky Digital moved the flows onto standard Klaviyo triggers, rebuilt the program around the brand’s best sellers, and planned two major sales inside the first 90 days. The work includes:

  • Rebuilt the welcome, browse abandonment, winback, post-purchase, back in stock and order delivered flows, with a three-email cross-sell flow next.
  • Redesigned the abandoned checkout flow and fixed timing on post-purchase emails.
  • Built and ran the April Semi-Annual Sale and Memorial Day within the first 90 days, with VIP early access the day before general access, plain text reminders and evening resends.
  • Shifted everyday sends toward product spotlights and education, such as a Supima cotton feature and an underwear guide for every life moment.
  • Updated pop-ups and signup forms to grow the email and SMS lists, with regular list hygiene to protect inbox placement.

Are your core flows running on someone else’s setup?

Get my free audit

The results

In April and May 2026, campaign revenue per recipient rose 13% year over year, net email subscribes rose 40%, and click-through rate rose 80%. Over the first six months, the rebuilt automations carried more of the load and engagement climbed.

  • Abandoned checkout revenue rose 58.7% year over year and revenue per recipient rose 50% after the redesign.
  • The rebuilt post-purchase flow lifted revenue 174.5% and revenue per recipient 28%.
  • The SMS welcome series more than doubled revenue, up 105.9%, with revenue per recipient up 20.9%.
  • Campaign revenue per recipient rose 13% year over year while the brand sent 36% fewer campaigns.
  • Net SMS subscriber growth rose 378% year over year and net email growth 104%, after the pop-up and form updates.
  • Email open rate rose from 58.16% to 61.4% and click rate from 0.51% to 0.61%, with spam complaints at 0.007%.
  • The Supima cotton spotlight was the top non-promotional email of the period, earning $9,961 at a 75.5% open rate.

Last 12 months, per Hiro Analytics: Klaviyo-attributed revenue made up 33.3% of Hanky Panky's store revenue in the 12 months to November 17, 2026.

“This is truly the best mix of great photos and fun copy and best ecom practices.”

Ellie M., Director of Ecommerce, Hanky Panky

Why it worked

Owning the automations changed the math. Once the flows ran on the brand’s own triggers and designs, every abandoned checkout, first purchase and new SMS subscriber got a journey built for Hanky Panky, and the campaign calendar could send less often while earning more per send.

Want results like these?

Every Sticky Digital engagement starts with a free retention audit: 35 to 40 pages, delivered in 3 to 5 days. See our pricing and our retention services.

Get my free 35+ page audit

More results: all Sticky Digital case studies.

Back to blog