Subscription

Retention for subscription brands. Fewer cancels. Fewer failed charges.

Sticky Digital builds lifecycle email and SMS for subscription brands on Recharge, Skio, Stay.ai and Ordergroove, including Kudos, Elix, Tubby Todd, Divi and Pretty Litter. We work the three places subscribers leave: between the first and second order, at the cancel button, and at a failed payment.

Klaviyo Platinum Partner · Attentive, Tie, Yotpo and Hiro Analytics advisory boards · Digioh Top Partner · 100+ brands since 2019

Last updated November 19, 2026

The short answer

What a subscription retention agency should do

A retention agency for a subscription brand should cut churn in two places. Voluntary churn needs a save path before the cancel click. Involuntary churn, when a payment fails, needs a recovery sequence that gets the card updated. Both get reported separately. The same program should grow order value with add-ons ahead of each renewal. Sticky Digital has done only retention since 2019, and most brands we work with reach 25% to 40% of store revenue from email within six months.

  • Retention only since 2019
  • Klaviyo Platinum Partner
  • Free 35 to 40 page audit in 3 to 5 days
  • Retainers from $4,500 a month
Results

Numbers from brands like yours.

−20%

Total churn from subscription flows

Elix →
+356%

Klaviyo-attributed revenue

Kudos →
$2.1M

Email and SMS revenue in 90 days, August 20 to November 18, 2026, per Hiro Analytics

Pretty Litter
Brands we’ve worked withKudosElixTubby ToddDiviPretty LitterUqoraRoutine Wellness

Every figure links to a published case study or cites Hiro Analytics with dates. See all case studies.

What’s different

Subscribers leave in three places. We build for all three.

Between the first and second order

The first renewal is where most subscriptions break. Our Kudos work focused on exactly that first-to-second order churn.

At the cancel button

A pause, a swap or a new cadence saves subscribers a discount can’t. We test save offers against your own cancellation reasons.

At a failed payment

Across 310,076 live subscriptions we analyzed in October 2026, 20.1% were already in payment retry. A dunning flow is usually the fastest money we find.

What we run

The program we build for subscription brands.

Email, SMS and loyalty working as one system, in the order that protects revenue first.

  1. 01

    First-box onboarding

    Setting expectations before the first renewal charges.

  2. 02

    Renewal reminders

    Notices before each charge, with an easy way to skip or swap.

  3. 03

    Cancellation save

    Pause, swap and cadence offers matched to the reason given.

  4. 04

    Failed payment recovery

    Dunning that works with your platform’s retry schedule.

  5. 05

    Milestone gifts

    Rewards at the order counts where subscribers usually drop.

  6. 06

    Win-back

    Bringing cancelled subscribers back with a reason to return.

Platforms we run every week

Recharge, Skio, Stay.ai and Ordergroove. Wired into your email and SMS.

We build on the subscription platform you already have. These are the four our team works in every week, and the subscriber events we build from.

  • Recharge

    Subscription started, skipped, order upcoming and payment failed, each with its own path, plus cancellation save offers and subscriber win-back.

    Josie Maran · GAT Sport · It’s My Leche · Natural Healthy Concepts · Three Farm Daughters
  • Skio

    Onboarding split for new and returning subscribers, skip recovery, cadence-change saves on cancel, churned-subscriber win-back and renewal texts.

    IQBAR · Somnee · Ranavat
  • Stay.ai

    Cancellation, billing failed and churn-risk flows, with cancellation surveys and punch-card rewards built in.

    Outerseas · Refresh Gum · Ascent Nutrition
  • Ordergroove

    Subscription welcome, order reminders, skips, cancellations, expiring-card alerts and churn cohort analysis.

    ZO Skin
FAQ

Questions from subscription brands

Straight answers on fit, cost and how we start.

Ask us something else

What should a subscription brand look for in a retention agency?

Look for hands-on work in your subscription platform, a dunning plan, and churn numbers from brands like yours. Sticky Digital works across Recharge, Skio, Stay.ai and Ordergroove and offers a $1,500 subscription deep dive audit alongside the free retention audit.

How much does Sticky Digital cost?

Retainers start at $4,500 a month. Email and SMS tiers run $5,500, $8,000, $12,000 and $15,000 a month. Every retainer starts with a six-month minimum, then runs month to month with 30 days notice. See full pricing.

Which platforms do you work in?

We’re platform agnostic. We run programs in Klaviyo, Attentive and Postscript, and we migrate brands between them. Sticky Digital is a Klaviyo Platinum Partner, sits on the Attentive, Tie, Yotpo and Hiro Analytics advisory boards, and is a Digioh Top Partner.

How does working with Sticky Digital start?

Every engagement starts with a free 35 to 40 page audit of your email and SMS program, delivered in 3 to 5 days. It’s yours to keep whether or not we work together. If you hire us, the first 90 days follow a set onboarding plan, and campaigns go out from the calendar we set in week one. See the first 90 days.

How much revenue should email drive for a subscription brand?

For most brands we work with, email reaches 25% to 40% of store revenue within six months. Where a subscription brand lands depends on list size, how often you launch, and how much of the catalog gets reordered. The free audit shows where your program sits today and what is holding it back.

What is the difference between voluntary and involuntary churn?

Voluntary churn is a customer choosing to cancel. Involuntary churn is a subscription that ends because a payment failed. They need different fixes: a save offer does nothing for a declined card, and a card update email does nothing for someone with too much product. We track and report the two separately.

Which subscription platforms do you work with?

Recharge, Skio and Stay.ai, alongside Klaviyo, Attentive and Postscript. We build flows from the subscription events those platforms send, like upcoming orders, failed payments and cancellations.

Let’s stick together

You make the connections. We make them stick.

Get a 35 to 40 page audit of your retention program, free, and a roadmap that’s yours to keep.

Get my free 35+ page audit

3 to 5 days. Manager access and an NDA. We start up to 15 new brands per quarter.