Email and SMS for food and beverage brands. Make the next order a habit.
Sticky Digital runs email, SMS and subscription retention for DTC food, snack and beverage brands, including Smith Teamaker, Alaskan Salmon Co., Clevr Blends, IQBAR, Gardencup, Refresh Gum and Franklin’s Gourmet Popcorn. Consumables live and die on the reorder, so we time every message to how fast your customers actually finish the product.
Klaviyo Platinum Partner · Attentive, Tie, Yotpo and Hiro Analytics advisory boards · Digioh Top Partner · 100+ brands since 2019
Last updated November 19, 2026
What a food and beverage retention agency should do
A retention agency for a food, beverage or consumables brand should build the habit. That means a welcome that gets the first reorder, replenishment timed to how fast a bag, box or case actually runs out, subscription offers on the products people buy every month, and seasonal launches that bring lapsed buyers back. Sticky Digital has done only retention since 2019, and most brands we work with reach 25% to 40% of store revenue from email within six months.
- Retention only since 2019
- Klaviyo Platinum Partner
- Free 35 to 40 page audit in 3 to 5 days
- Retainers from $4,500 a month
Numbers from brands like yours.
Attributed revenue, January 2025 to January 2026 vs. the prior 13 months
Alaskan Salmon Co. →+75%Flow placed-order rate from time delays and flow filter auditing
Smith Teamaker →+202%BFCM SMS campaign revenue, year over year
Gardencup →Every figure links to a published case study or cites Hiro Analytics with dates. See all case studies.
Consumption sets the clock. Your flows should keep time.
Reorder timing is the whole game
In three accounts we checked, half to two thirds of the customers who reordered within a year had done it by day 90. The first replenishment nudge belongs ahead of your average reorder gap, not at it.
Flavor fatigue is real
Customers who love one flavor eventually want another. Cross-sell by what they bought keeps them in your catalog instead of trying a competitor.
Gifting and seasons move volume
Holiday boxes and seasonal flavors bring a spike of new buyers. At Gardencup, BFCM SMS campaign revenue rose 202% year over year.
The program we build for food and beverage brands.
Email, SMS and loyalty working as one system, in the order that protects revenue first.
- 01
Replenishment
Reorder reminders timed to how fast each product gets used.
- 02
Subscribe and save
Moving repeat buyers onto subscription when they reorder.
- 03
Flavor cross-sell
Recommendations based on what they bought and what pairs with it.
- 04
Gifting
Gift guides, corporate orders and holiday shipping deadlines.
- 05
Win-back
Lapsed customers brought back before they settle on someone else.
- 06
SMS for limited runs
Texts for seasonal flavors, restocks and sellouts.
Questions from food and beverage brands
Straight answers on fit, cost and how we start.
Ask us something elseWhat should a food or beverage brand look for in a retention agency?
Look for replenishment timing built on your own reorder data, subscription experience, and proof from food or beverage brands. Sticky Digital has run retention for Smith Teamaker, Alaskan Salmon Co., Clevr Blends and Gardencup.
How much does Sticky Digital cost?
Retainers start at $4,500 a month. Email and SMS tiers run $5,500, $8,000, $12,000 and $15,000 a month. Every retainer starts with a six-month minimum, then runs month to month with 30 days notice. See full pricing.
Which platforms do you work in?
We’re platform agnostic. We run programs in Klaviyo, Attentive and Postscript, and we migrate brands between them. Sticky Digital is a Klaviyo Platinum Partner, sits on the Attentive, Tie, Yotpo and Hiro Analytics advisory boards, and is a Digioh Top Partner.
How does working with Sticky Digital start?
Every engagement starts with a free 35 to 40 page audit of your email and SMS program, delivered in 3 to 5 days. It’s yours to keep whether or not we work together. If you hire us, the first 90 days follow a set onboarding plan, and campaigns go out from the calendar we set in week one. See the first 90 days.
How much revenue should email drive for a food or beverage brand?
For most brands we work with, email reaches 25% to 40% of store revenue within six months. Where a food or beverage brand lands depends on list size, how often you launch, and how much of the catalog gets reordered. The free audit shows where your program sits today and what is holding it back.
How often should a food and beverage brand send email?
Often enough to match how fast customers use the product, and no more. We set cadence from your reorder data and engagement, send more to active buyers and less to people who have not opened in months, which protects deliverability for the whole list.
Should a consumables brand push subscriptions?
On the products people reorder on a steady schedule, yes. We offer subscription after the second purchase on those items, when the customer already knows they like it, and we keep one-time buyers of seasonal or gift items out of subscription pushes.
From our blog

You make the connections. We make them stick.
Get a 35 to 40 page audit of your retention program, free, and a roadmap that’s yours to keep.
Get my free 35+ page audit3 to 5 days. Manager access and an NDA. We start up to 15 new brands per quarter.