Smith Teamaker Case Study: 75% Higher Flow Order Rate, featured image from Sticky Digital

Smith Teamaker Case Study: 75% Higher Flow Order Rate

Last updated

Smith Teamaker raised its flow placed-order rate 75% after Sticky Digital overhauled its flows with loyalty blocks, subscription perks and better post-purchase timing.

Beverage · Email, SMS, loyalty and subscription

+75%Flow placed-order rate from time delays and flow filter auditing
+20%SMS conversion rate from segmentation optimization
+15%Flow click rate from updated timing

How we measured this

Results period: the engagement. Dates for the headline results are not disclosed. The share-of-revenue row covers the 12 months to November 17, 2026. This page was published on November 17, 2026.

Result Period Starting baseline How it is defined
Flow placed-order rate After the time delay and filter audit Level before the changes; value not disclosed Placed orders divided by recipients in flows.
SMS conversion rate After segmentation changes Level before the changes; value not disclosed Orders placed divided by recipients.
Flow click rate After the timing update Level before the changes; value not disclosed Share of delivered messages that received a click.
Klaviyo share of store revenue 12 months to November 17, 2026 Single-period share, no baseline Klaviyo-attributed revenue divided by total store revenue, from Hiro Analytics.

About Smith Teamaker

Smith Teamaker is a Portland tea maker with a loyalty program and tea subscriptions. Sticky Digital started with a retention audit and loyalty proposal in 2024, and in 2026 took on a full rebuild of the brand’s core flows.

The challenge

Smith Teamaker wanted its flows overhauled and strategically optimized. Several journeys were running on old timing and filters, so messages were not reaching subscribers and loyalty members at the right moment in their purchase cycle.

What we did

Sticky Digital audited flow time delays and filters, added loyalty blocks and subscription perks, adjusted post-purchase timing and delivery, and optimized SMS segmentation so messages met subscribers where they were in their purchasing journey. The 2026 flow rebuild covered:

  • Six new welcome emails, launched as a 50/50 split test against the old series so the winner was proven before it took over.
  • Three browse abandonment emails and two customer winback emails.
  • Three replenishment emails and three post-purchase emails alongside the Malomo shipping updates.
  • Loyalty blocks and subscription perks inside the flows, plus pop-up and abandonment flow strategy.

Are your flows still running on last year’s timing?

Get my free audit

The results

Flow placed-order rate rose 75%, SMS conversion rate rose 20%, and flow click rate rose 15%.

  • Flow placed-order rate rose 75% after the time delay and filter audit.
  • SMS conversion rate rose 20% from better segmentation.
  • Flow click rate rose 15% from updated timing.

Last 12 months, per Hiro Analytics: Klaviyo-attributed revenue grew 9.8% over the prior 12 months and made up 51.3% of Smith Teamaker's store revenue in the 12 months to November 17, 2026.

“The team is incredible to work with, and the designs are right on brand.”

Jane W., Lifecycle Marketing, Smith Teamaker

Why it worked

Timing is strategy for a replenishable product. Matching every flow to where the customer sits in the tea cycle, and testing the new welcome series against the old one, meant every change had to earn its place.

Want results like these?

Every Sticky Digital engagement starts with a free retention audit: 35 to 40 pages, delivered in 3 to 5 days. See our pricing and our retention services.

Get my free 35+ page audit

More results: all Sticky Digital case studies.

Back to blog