Routine Wellness Case Study: A Same-Day Domain Change With 99.9% Delivery, featured image from Sticky Digital

Routine Wellness Case Study: A Same-Day Domain Change With 99.9% Delivery

Last updated

Sticky Digital moved Routine Wellness to a new sending domain the same afternoon its rebranded site went live. The first email from the new domain reached 99.9% of recipients.

Health and wellness · August to September 2026 · Klaviyo and domain migration

11Flows relaunched on cutover day
99.9%Delivered on the first new-domain send
65%Open rate on the day-one send

How we measured this

Results period: August to September 2026, the day the rebranded site went live and the new sending domain took over. This page was published on November 17, 2026.

Result Period Starting baseline How it is defined
Flows relaunched Cutover day None on the new domain before cutover Klaviyo flows rebuilt in the new brand and live on the new sending domain.
Delivery rate First send from the new domain First send on the new domain, no baseline Share of recipients whose mail server accepted the email.
Open rate Day-one send First send on the new domain, no baseline Share of delivered emails with a recorded open. Opens include automated opens from Apple Mail Privacy Protection, so compare within one account, not across brands.

About Routine Wellness

Routine Wellness is a wellness brand that went through a full rebrand in 2026, moving from routinecos.com to routinewellness.com. Sticky Digital has run the brand’s retention program since its retention audit in the fall of 2025, so the email and SMS side of the rebrand sat with the same team that knew the account.

The challenge

Midway through its rebrand, Routine Wellness moved from routinecos.com to routinewellness.com. Every flow and the sending domain had to move with it without hurting deliverability. A new sending domain starts with no reputation, and a domain switch done in a hurry can push a brand’s best customers into spam for weeks.

The brand also needed every customer-facing touchpoint, from signup forms to consent pages to the links inside each email, to match the new name the moment the site went live.

What we did

Sticky Digital rebuilt 11 Klaviyo flows in the new brand identity, set up and authenticated the new sending domain, and switched every flow over the same afternoon the site went live. The work ran from a single migration board:

  • Confirmed scope and the launch plan, built a full inventory of every flow, template, form and link that had to change, and aligned with the brand on risk and pacing before anything moved.
  • Chose a domain warming strategy and built warm-up segments of the most engaged subscribers.
  • Duplicated every priority flow and email template in the new brand identity, and updated brand settings, signup forms and consent pages.
  • Replaced old links everywhere and ran a full QA pass before launch day.
  • On launch day, confirmed the new site and tracking were live, switched the sender, activated the new flows and verified every link.
  • Followed the warming plan after the first campaign, scaling volume as the new domain built its reputation.

Rebranding or changing domains?

Get my free audit

The results

The first email sent from the new domain was delivered to 99.9% of recipients and opened by 65% of them. Every flow was live on the new domain the same day the new site launched.

  • 11 flows relaunched in the new brand on cutover day.
  • 99.9% of recipients received the first email from the new domain.
  • 65% of recipients opened that first send.

Why it worked

Everything was built and tested before launch day, so the switch itself was a checklist, not a scramble. Starting the new domain with the most engaged subscribers gave it a clean reputation from the first send.

Want results like these?

Every Sticky Digital engagement starts with a free retention audit: 35 to 40 pages, delivered in 3 to 5 days. See our pricing and our retention services. Moving platforms? See how we run email and SMS migrations.

Get my free 35+ page audit

More results: all Sticky Digital case studies.

Back to blog