Paid Retargeting Guide for Past Customers: How Sticky Digital Uses Paid Media to Reactivate Lapsed Buyers

Every retention marketer eventually faces the same question: 
“What do we do with customers who no longer open our emails or tap our SMS?”

In the lifecycle world, we talk constantly about flows, segmentation, loyalty, and subscription—but there’s a powerful re-engagement lever most Shopify brands underuse:
Paid retargeting campaigns built specifically for past customers.

Not cold audiences. Not broad remarketing pools. Not “everyone who visited the site.” But past purchasers—the people who already know your brand, have already trusted you enough to buy, and may simply need the right moment, message, or reminder to return.

This high-efficiency tactic often gets overshadowed by lifecycle channels, but the truth is simple:
Past-customer retargeting performs 2–6× better than standard cold ads.

To help brands use this advantage intentionally—not randomly—we built the Sticky Digital Paid Retargeting Guide for Past Customers (PDF).

This guide gives Shopify brands a complete retargeting architecture that integrates directly with email and SMS, supporting full-funnel lifecycle strategy—something we outline in detail here:
Email, SMS, Loyalty & Subscriptions: The Full-Stack Retention Ecosystem Explained.

Below, we’ll walk through each component of the guide and how it strengthens your retention ecosystem.

What’s Inside the Paid Retargeting Guide for Past Customers

The guide is structured like every Sticky Digital deliverable: consulting-grade, minimal, brand-aligned, and written to empower operators—not overwhelm them.

Inside, you’ll find six core components:

  1. Past-Customer Retargeting Strategy Overview
  2. Audience Setup Checklist (Meta + Google)
  3. Text-Based Retargeting Flowchart
  4. Creative Guidelines Built for Retention
  5. Sample High-Converting Ad Copy
  6. Budget Planner

Let’s explore each section and how it helps your team build a retargeting strategy that actually complements lifecycle—not competes with it.

1️⃣ Past-Customer Retargeting Strategy Overview

The playbook begins with what most brands misunderstand:
Retargeting past customers is not the same as retargeting warm prospects.

Past customers have:

  • product familiarity
  • brand affinity
  • a previous purchase to anchor messaging to
  • existing preferences you can tailor ads around

Even if they’ve “gone dark” on email or SMS, paid retargeting can re-open a door that lifecycle touches can’t reach anymore.

Three key principles inside the guide:

1. Past buyers respond to emotional context

Unlike cold ads, which must educate the user from scratch, past-customer ads can:

  • remind them what they loved
  • resolve concerns from their first order
  • highlight relevant upgrades
  • spark recognition with imagery alone

2. Paid retargeting fills lifecycle gaps

The guide explains how paid retargeting can support:

  • post-purchase drop-off
  • replenishment cycles
  • subscription rescue
  • loyalty reactivation
  • under-engaged customer segments

When email and SMS engagement drop, paid gives you a final, scalable route back in.

3. Retargeting should align with lifecycle—not work against it

The guide shows how to synchronize your channels:

  • Email → education & reassurance
  • SMS → urgency & nudges
  • Paid → visual reminders & re-engagement

Most agencies blast ads without considering where customers are in their lifecycle.
This guide fixes that.

2️⃣ Audience Setup Checklist (Meta + Google)

One of the biggest mistakes we see in audits is sloppy audience setup. This leads to wasted spend, low ROAS, and ads hitting people who either don’t need them—or aren’t ready.

The guide includes a consulting-grade audience checklist that ensures your retargeting is:

  • clean
  • focused
  • lifecycle-aware
  • suppression-safe

The Checklist Covers:

  • CRM list sync (Klaviyo ↔ Meta + Google)
  • Lookback windows (14, 30, 60, 90, 180+ day purchasers)
  • Replenishment timing based on SKU/category
  • High-lapse audiences for strategic winback
  • Pixel warm pools for onsite + browse behavior
  • Suppression lists to protect margin & frequency

This checklist ensures your ads reach the right people instead of wasting spend on over-served, low-probability segments.

This mirrors the segmentation frameworks we outline in:
Retention Templates & Assets.

3️⃣ Text-Based Retargeting Flowchart

Inside the guide you'll find a clean, text-based flowchart built for SOPs, internal decks, and lifecycle documentation.

This flowchart maps:

  • Days since last purchase → audience tier
  • Email/SMS activity → frequency rules
  • Segment value (AOV/LTV) → creative/offer differentiation

The logic looks like this (simplified):

IF 10–20 days inactive → Replenishment ads
ELSE IF 20–45 days inactive → Light product reminders
ELSE IF 45–90 days inactive → Benefit-led win-back
ELSE IF 90–180 days inactive → Offer-eligible tier
ELSE → “Comeback” ads w/ soft emotional framing

This visual logic keeps teams aligned across paid, email, and SMS so channels never contradict each other.

4️⃣ Creative Guidelines Built for Retention

Retention-optimized ad creative looks different from acquisition creative.

The guide outlines the four principles of high-performing retention ads:

1. Spark Recognition Instantly

Use familiar packaging, signature textures, scents, bundles, or brand colors so the ad feels “known” rather than foreign.

2. Use Benefit-Led Messaging (Not Lifestyle Abstraction)

Retention ads should remind customers of the outcome they experienced (or wanted to experience), not overload them with aspirational imagery.

3. Address Objections Head-On

  • “Didn’t see results?” → education-based creative
  • “Stopped using regularly?” → routine reminders
  • “Ran out?” → replenishment messaging

4. Layer Offers Only When Necessary

The guide explains exactly when to introduce:

  • non-financial nudges
  • soft incentives
  • VIP-specific offers
  • threshold-based discounts

The goal is to re-engage customers without degrading brand value or training discount expectations.

5️⃣ Sample High-Converting Ad Copy

The guide includes ready-to-use templates for different lifecycle segments, such as:

⭐ Benefit-Led Reminder Ads

“Your favorites are waiting for you. Ready to restock?”

⭐ Offer-Based Win-Back Ads

“A little thank-you for coming back: $10 credit inside.”

⭐ Product-Forward Messaging

“The routine that started it all—back on your shelf?”

⭐ Routine Refresh Ads

“Your routine evolves. So should your essentials. See what’s new.”

All copy is written in a compliance-friendly, value-first voice aligned with Sticky Digital’s brand.

6️⃣ Budget Planner

Paid retargeting often gets ignored because teams don’t know how much to spend—or worse, they overspend by blending past purchasers with broad remarketing.

The guide includes a simple but powerful budget planner with:

  • Impression targets based on audience size
  • CPM ranges typical for Meta + Google
  • Spend forecasting by tier
  • Expected ROAS bands for each window
  • Scale-up rules based on early performance

This takes the guesswork out of planning and helps your team scale profitably instead of reactively.

📄 Download the Paid Retargeting Guide for Past Customers

You can download the full guide here:
Download the Paid Retargeting Guide for Past Customers (PDF)

The PDF is fully formatted with Sticky Digital’s brand standards:

  • Midnight Mesa (#254D63) headers
  • Bitter + Montserrat typography
  • Neutral consulting palette
  • Slide-ready layout for internal enablement

How This Guide Fits Into Your Lifecycle Strategy

Paid

Back to blog