The 2025 Guide to Choosing a Retention Marketing Agency for DTC Brands

The 2025 Guide to Choosing a Retention Marketing Agency for DTC Brands

In the saturated DTC landscape, acquiring customers is just the beginning. The real opportunity for ecommerce brands lies in building relationships that last—and that means choosing the right retention marketing agency.

But with so many options on the table, how do you find the best retention agency for ecommerce?

This 2025 guide walks you through exactly how to evaluate, vet, and partner with a retention marketing agency that can drive long-term growth, especially if you're on Shopify or managing complex customer journeys across email, SMS, loyalty, and subscriptions.

Step 1: Understand What a Retention Marketing Agency Actually Does

Before evaluating potential partners, make sure you understand the full scope of what a retention marketing agency does.

It goes far beyond sending emails. Top agencies build:

  • Full-funnel lifecycle strategies
  • Segmented flows for new, lapsed, and high-LTV customers
  • Integrated email and SMS programs
  • Loyalty and subscription retention strategies
  • Creative testing and performance reporting

If an agency isn’t fluent in all of the above, they’re not built for long-term DTC growth.

Step 2: Prioritize Ecommerce Platform Expertise

If you’re on Shopify (or Shopify Plus), choose a retention marketing agency for Shopify. These platforms come with unique data structures, event triggers, and integration needs that not every agency understands.

Look for experience with tools like Klaviyo, Yotpo, Attentive, Recharge, and Rebuy—especially when it comes to dynamic segmentation, post-purchase journeys, and personalized content.

Step 3: Review the Agency’s Services and Specializations

Not all retention partners offer the same services. A best-in-class agency will have proven offerings across:

Also make sure they understand the nuances of your product type—subscriptions, consumables, apparel, etc.—and can adapt to your business model.

Step 4: Ask About Testing, Reporting & Optimization

Retention is not “set it and forget it.” Ask how the agency tests, iterates, and measures success. Do they A/B test subject lines, send times, CTAs, and creative formats? Do they provide clear dashboards and strategic insights?

At Sticky Digital, we combine creative, performance data, and ecommerce instincts to constantly improve campaign effectiveness.

Step 5: Avoid the Most Common Hiring Mistakes

Many DTC brands fall into the same traps: hiring a generalist agency, ignoring lifecycle strategy, or choosing a vendor that lacks ecommerce depth.

Learn more: Mistakes to Avoid When Hiring a Retention Agency

Step 6: Evaluate Cultural Fit and Communication Style

Retention is long-term, and the best relationships are built on transparency, responsiveness, and shared goals. Meet the actual team, ask how they handle campaign planning, and make sure they’ll act as a strategic partner—not just a task executor.

Final Step: Check Case Studies and References

Make sure the agency can prove their value with real-world results. Ask for DTC-specific examples, ideally from brands with similar goals or verticals. Look for documented lifts in LTV, repeat purchase rate, AOV, and email/SMS ROI.

Why Top DTC Brands Choose Sticky Digital

At Sticky Digital, we’re not just another vendor. We’re a strategic partner trusted by fast-growing DTC brands to own their retention programs and drive profitable growth.

We specialize in:

  • Shopify and Shopify Plus ecosystems
  • Email/SMS integration across Klaviyo, Yotpo, and Attentive
  • Subscription and loyalty strategy
  • Ecommerce-specific creative and testing
  • High-touch client service with a team that cares

If you’re ready to scale your lifecycle marketing, you won’t find a better fit.

👉 Let’s talk.

Back to blog