Creative Testing Strategies Leading Into BFCM

How to test email and SMS creative pre-BFCM for best results.

Black Friday and Cyber Monday (BFCM) aren’t just the biggest sales events of the year — they’re also the most competitive. Customers are flooded with subject lines, offers, and text alerts, making creative execution the difference between a scroll-past and a click.

But waiting until BFCM weekend to figure out what works is a costly mistake. The brands that consistently outperform know this: creative testing before BFCM is one of the highest-ROI activities you can run.

At Sticky Digital, we help Shopify brands design BFCM creative testing strategies that maximize open rates, conversions, and retention. Here’s how to structure your testing window to enter November with confidence.

Why Creative Testing Before BFCM Is Critical

  1. Crowded inboxes, higher stakes — Even small optimizations (subject lines, hero image variations, CTA placement) can swing conversion by double digits when competition is fierce.
  2. Time to iterate — Testing in October (or earlier) gives you data-backed insights to roll into your November campaigns.
  3. Reduced risk — Pre-BFCM testing ensures your “biggest” emails and SMS sends are based on proven creative decisions, not guesswork.

What to Test in Email Before BFCM

Focus on variables that influence conversion most directly:

  • Subject lines & preheaders: urgency vs. curiosity; emojis vs. clean copy; brand-first vs. product-first framing.
  • Hero creative: lifestyle vs. product-forward images; seasonal vs. evergreen visuals.
  • CTA placement & style: above-the-fold buttons vs. below; bold colors vs. brand palette.
  • Offer framing: percentage off vs. dollar savings; tiered structures vs. simple discounts.

Even small wins here multiply during high-volume BFCM campaigns. Explore more in our Creative Services.

What to Test in SMS Before BFCM

SMS is direct, urgent, and often under-optimized. Pre-BFCM testing should include:

  • Message length: single-line urgency blasts vs. multi-line storytelling.
  • CTA format: direct “Shop Now” links vs. personalized deep links.
  • Send times: morning vs. evening across segments.
  • Tone & style: conversational vs. straightforward promotional.

Because SMS has high open rates, testing tone and CTA clarity often yields the biggest lifts.

How to Structure Your BFCM Creative Tests

  1. Start early: Run tests at least 4–6 weeks before BFCM to gather statistically significant results.
  2. Test one variable at a time: Isolate subject lines, heroes, or CTAs to know what moved the needle.
  3. Use control groups: Maintain a baseline version of creative for comparison.
  4. Leverage automation & flows: Insert creative variations into existing flows (welcome, post-purchase, win-back) to test at scale without over-emailing your list.
  5. Segment for insights: Break down results by lifecycle stage, AOV, or VIP status.

See our Segmentation Strategies for BFCM.

What Metrics to Track

  • Email: open rate, click-through rate (CTR), revenue per recipient (RPR).
  • SMS: click rate, conversion rate, opt-out rate.
  • Cross-channel: lift in AOV, repeat purchase rate, unsubscribes/complaints.

The right KPIs ensure you’re testing for conversion outcomes, not vanity metrics.

Building a Repeatable Creative Testing Framework

The most successful brands don’t treat creative testing as a one-off BFCM project. They build repeatable systems that compound learning:

  • Testing → Insights → Iteration → Scaling
  • Continuous testing informs creative excellence not just for BFCM, but across every lifecycle campaign.

Learn how testing integrates into a broader retention roadmap.

Final Word: Test Before the Stakes Are Highest

BFCM creative testing is about confidence. Entering November with data-backed insights ensures your biggest campaigns aren’t experiments — they’re optimized growth engines. With inboxes and SMS feeds more crowded than ever, testing is the lever that transforms creative from “good enough” into conversion-driving assets.

🎨 Learn More: Creative Testing Services 📚 Read: Retention-Focused Creative Testing

Back to blog